Gluten-Free NYC: Where We Ate, What to Order & What to Skip
Ten years ago, eating gluten-free and dairy-free while traveling meant packing a suitcase of snacks and hoping for a sad salad. True story.
So when my nephew got married in upstate New York, my sisters and I turned it into our annual girls’ trip and spent three days in NYC first. I’d only been once, at 18, and didn’t remember much.
Here’s what surprised me. Finding gluten-free food in New York was NOT the hard part. There were more gluten-free options than we could possibly eat in three days (though we tried hard).
The tricky part is finding the dream-worthy stuff. The food that fits your allergens AND is worth the subway ride.
So this is my honest list: where we ate, exactly what to order, what I’d skip, and the reader-recommended spots we ran out of time for.

If you’re new to eating this way on the road, start with my gluten-free dairy-free travel guide. It’s how I plan every trip.
Why You’ll Love This Guide
- It’s honest. I tell you what was amazing AND what didn’t live up to the hype.
- It’s specific. You get the exact items to order, not just restaurant names.
- Gluten-free and dairy-free. I flag the 100% gluten-free spots and where dairy-free gets tricky.
- Reader-sourced. Many of these spots came from y’all when I asked for recommendations on Instagram.
- Built for a short trip. Most spots are in Manhattan and easy to reach by subway or on foot.
Where We Ate in NYC (and What to Order)
Modern Bread & Bagel — Multiple Manhattan Locations
This was the only place so good we went TWICE. These are the best gluten-free bagels I’ve ever had. Period.
Everything is 100% gluten-free (and kosher), and a lot of the menu is labeled dairy-free.

FAVORITE ITEMS
- Pretzel bagel — My favorite. I loved it. (It’s labeled dairy-free on their menu.)
- Jerusalem egg salad sandwich — I was a little nervous about the capers and dill, but you don’t taste them. It just tastes delicious.
- Morning Stretch — An egg sandwich with a red pesto (sun-dried tomato and red pepper). Delicious, but a little too messy for me.
- Chocolate babka — Amazing. Get it.
- Strawberry glazed donut — I didn’t love the frosting, but the donut itself was a tall, soft raised donut that was still soft the next day.

Skip: The pumpkin babka my sister got was just okay.
My one regret: I wish I’d bought a bag of bagels to take home. The good news? They ship nationwide, so you can order them even if you’re not going to New York.
📍 Upper West Side (472 Columbus Ave, closed Saturdays), Upper East Side (1427 3rd Ave), Chelsea (139 W 14th St), Midtown (630 Lexington Ave), Tribeca (130 Duane St)
WEBSITE: modernbreadandbagel.com
Posh Pop Bakeshop — Greenwich Village, Midtown & Upper West Side
A 100% gluten-free bakery, and our dessert haul was so worth it.

FAVORITE ITEMS
- Fried churro Oreos — Amazing. Eat them warm.
- Fluffer butter brownie — Absolutely delicious.
- S’mores bar — Also absolutely delicious.
- Cinnamon roll — Good, but probably amazing warm. Ask them to heat it up.
A note: Posh Pop is gluten-free, not dairy-free. Some items contain dairy, so ask at the counter.

📍 154 Bleecker St (Greenwich Village), 315 W 39th St (near Times Square), 483 Columbus Ave (Upper West Side)
Senza Gluten — Greenwich Village & Hell’s Kitchen
Everything here is gluten-free, and it’s yummy Italian food.
We loved the bread, the chicken parm, and the Brussels sprouts. (If you want chicken parm at home, here’s my gluten-free dairy-free chicken parmesan.)

FAVORITE ITEMS
- Bread for the table
- Chicken parm – This had good flavor, and I enjoyed it, but the breading did fall off a bit.
- Brussels sprouts – Perfectly tender but with crispy bits. Yum!
Heads up: They only take cash or American Express, and it’s a little more expensive.
📍 206 Sullivan St (Greenwich Village) and Senza Gluten by Jemiko, 626 10th Ave (Hell’s Kitchen)
Jack’s All Day — Hell’s Kitchen (Near the Theaters)
Almost their entire menu is gluten-free, which makes it an easy pick before a Broadway show.

FAVORITE ITEMS
- Gluten-free onion rings — Loved them.
- Turkey sandwich — Loved it too.
Skip: The burger was solid but nothing amazing.
A note: If you have celiac disease, ask about their kitchen. It’s gluten-free-focused, but I couldn’t confirm it’s a dedicated gluten-free kitchen.
📍 731 8th Ave
Van Leeuwen — Multiple Locations
So many vegan flavors, and YUM. I couldn’t tell they were dairy-free.
My favorite was the chocolate pecan. The Times Square shop (712 7th Ave) is open late, so it’s perfect after a show.

A note: The vegan scoops are dairy-free, but ask about cones and mix-ins if you need gluten-free.
Want it at home? Here’s my easy dairy-free ice cream.
Friedman’s — Multiple Locations
I LOVED how clearly their menu is marked, and there are lots of gluten-free options.
But I didn’t love the chicken and waffles. The chicken was on the bone (not strips), so it was hard to eat with the waffle. And the cheddar waffle was too dense for me, and I couldn’t taste the cheddar.
My sister loved her gluten-free fish and chips, though. I’d totally go again and order something else, they have a ton of GF Chinese food that looked tasty!

Order: Gluten-free fish and chips
Skip: Chicken and waffles
📍 Locations include Chelsea Market, Battery Park City (245 Murray St, handy after the Statue of Liberty and the 9/11 Memorial), Times Square (228 W 47th St), and Hudson Yards (450 10th Ave)
Don Antonio — Hell’s Kitchen
This one gets recommended a LOT for gluten-free pizza, so I had high hopes.
The gluten-free dough had excellent crispiness. But it felt like I was just eating cheese bread, and it was a bit dry. We got the pistachio pesto pizza and I sadly didn’t taste much flavor.
And the waiter was insulted when I asked for marinara dipping sauce. (Oops.)

What was good: The gluten-free crust had a great texture and crisp. I would get it again just a different flavor. The gluten-free fritti was tasty, but literally 3 smaller than my thumb for like $15. Not worth the cost IMO unless cost just isn’t a big deal for you.
Dairy-free? No dairy-free options.
📍 309 W 50th St
Places We Didn’t Get To (What You Recommended)
There was way more amazing gluten-free food than we could eat in three days. These came up again and again in your recommendations and in gluten-free guides, and they’re first on my list next time.
By the Way Bakery — Upper West Side
Everything is gluten-free AND dairy-free. Two of my friends recommended it, and it shows up in nearly every gluten-free NYC guide.
What people recommend: The cream puff, lemon poppyseed mini bundt, linzer tart, whoopie pies, and seasonal fall treats.
📍 2440 Broadway
Wild — West Village
A 100% gluten-free restaurant that doesn’t take reservations.
What people recommend: The Caprino pizza, the meatballs with marinara, and the caramel cheesecake. You can swap in plant-based cheese on anything.
📍 535 Hudson St
Locanut — Chelsea
100% gluten-free and seed-oil free, with lots of dairy-free options. It’s two blocks from Chelsea Market and the High Line.
What people recommend: The ginger miso salmon, the chicken Caesar wrap, and a build-your-own bowl.
📍 361 W 17th St
Rubirosa — Nolita
It has a full gluten-free menu, and it was ranked #1 on Tasting Table’s list of the best gluten-free restaurants in NYC. Getting a table is tough, so plan ahead.
What people recommend: The vodka pizza or the Tie-Dye pizza (vodka sauce, red sauce, and pesto). Ask which pies come on the gluten-free crust.
📍 235 Mulberry St

Nizza — Hell’s Kitchen
It has a separate celiac-safe menu and is close to the theaters. Book ahead before a show.
What people recommend: The complimentary gluten-free focaccia, oven-baked gnocchi, and brick-oven mussels.
📍 630 9th Ave
Lilli & Loo — Chelsea
Chinese food with a dedicated gluten-free menu.
What people recommend: The gluten-free lo mein, General Tso’s chicken, gyoza, and spring rolls.
📍 198 9th Ave
Butterdose — East Village
A cute café where all the cream puffs are gluten-free.
What people recommend: The matcha strawberry and mixed berry cream puffs, plus the apple cider donut in the fall.
📍 236 E 13th St
Seed + Mill — Inside Chelsea Market
Vegan, gluten-free tahini soft serve topped with halva. Ask for an extra drizzle (it’s free).
📍 409 W 15th St (inside Chelsea Market)
What We Did (and What Was Worth It)
Not just food, I promise. Here’s what we did and what I’d tell a friend.
- A Broadway show (or two) — My sister does theater and sings, and I used to dance, so we grew up on musicals. We saw The Great Gatsby and Harry Potter and the Cursed Child. Both were so worth it.
- Statue of Liberty — I’d taken a ferry past it before, but loved going TO it this time. I was really struck by how beautiful it is, especially knowing it was built in the late 1800s.
- 9/11 Memorial & Museum — Very somber and beautiful. The museum is so well done. I cried.
- Brooklyn Bridge at sunset — I made my sister walk it with me even though we already had 20,000 steps that day. Worth it.
- A bike ride through Central Park — Such a lovely way to start the day. Don’t miss Bethesda Terrace. You have to be super patient to get a good photo there, but it’s worth it.
- Empire State Building — We didn’t pay to go to the top. We got great views from the ferry and the Brooklyn Bridge instead.

If you’re planning flights, here’s how I save thousands with travel hacking.
Gluten-Free NYC FAQ
Is it easy to eat gluten-free in New York City?
Yes. Easier than I expected. We had more gluten-free options than we could possibly eat in three days.
The harder part is finding the truly great spots, which is why I wrote this list.
Where can I find the best gluten-free bagels in NYC?
Modern Bread & Bagel. It’s 100% gluten-free, and they’re the best gluten-free bagels I’ve ever had. Get the pretzel bagel.
One heads-up: some regular bagel shops advertise a gluten-free bagel that turns out to be a packaged one. Ask before you go out of your way.
Which NYC spots are 100% gluten-free?
Of the places in this guide: Modern Bread & Bagel, Posh Pop Bakeshop, Senza Gluten, Wild, Locanut, By the Way Bakery, and Seed + Mill.
Is it hard to eat dairy-free in NYC?
It takes a little more asking. By the Way Bakery is fully dairy-free, Van Leeuwen has lots of vegan flavors, and many Modern Bread & Bagel items are labeled dairy-free.
Pizza spots are the trickiest. Don Antonio had no dairy-free options.
New to dairy-free? My dairy-free for beginners guide walks you through it.
Is Erin McKenna’s Bakery still open in NYC?
It was a popular recommendation, but its Lower East Side bakery appears to have closed. Modern Bread & Bagel signed a lease for the space at 248 Broome St.
How do you get around NYC without a car?
We walked and took the subway. You can just tap your credit card or phone at the turnstile.
For JFK, take the LIRR or the E train to Jamaica, then the AirTrain.
Other Travel Guides You’ll Love
Planning more trips? These will help.
- How to Travel Gluten-Free and Dairy-Free: A Real Mom’s Guide
- The Best Gluten-Free Restaurants in Utah Valley
- Flying with Allergen-Friendly Food to Hawaii on a Budget
- Save Thousands with Travel Hacking
- 100+ Gluten-Free Dairy-Free Snacks

















0 Comments